The political cartoon about the college student being Tased
because he was being removed from the auditorium where Senator John Kerry was
speaking is a favorite of mine. The student, Andrew Meyer, wanted to be heard.
He went up to the microphone to ask a question after the questioning had ended.
The University of Florida Campus Police proceeded to stop him and escort him
out of the auditorium because he became unruly. He would not comply, so they Tased
him. This argument is not very strong. The political cartoonist Brian
Farrington drew it after the incident. I think it proves a very good point, but
it does not have a strong argument. If you speak out against someone with a
Taser, you’re going to get Tased. This political cartoon is funny, and also
says that there is not any freedom of speech on a college campus. It makes a bad
argument because the cartoon depicts Meyers being Tased and there is a sign
reading “Warning: colleges are free speech free zones.” I like this political
cartoon for its creativity. While it may or may not be correct, I believe there
is freedom of speech on a college campus, just at the right place and the right
time. If you demand to be heard, people will not want to listen. He was
demanding to speak and became unruly, so he was detained. He is not making much of an argument by saying
there is no freedom of speech on college campuses. The only thing he has is the
sign that warns others.

I'm very confused here, Dylan. You say that argument isn't working, but yet you think it's funny and creative?
ReplyDelete